Costa Rica’s 5 Most Overrated Surf Spots (And Where to Go Instead)
Costa Rica, the ultimate surfer’s playground. With two breathtaking coastlines, a near-perfect blend of consistent swells, and vibrant local culture, it’s no wonder the country sits atop every surfer’s bucket list. But here’s the thing—not every location on the map is worth the hype. Costa Rica’s beauty and popularity mean some spots feel overcrowded, overhyped, or even oversold.
But don’t worry—there’s always an alternative. With a little insider knowledge and some pura vida attitude, you can sidestep the overrated and paddle into authentic, crowd-free surf heaven. Let's break down five surf towns and spots that might not live up to their reputation, plus where you should head instead for an unforgettable session.
1. Tamarindo
Why It’s Overrated
Known affectionately (or not) as “TamaGringo” by locals, Tamarindo has transformed from a laid-back surf town into the poster child of tourism-driven overdevelopment. While the main beach still has decent beginner waves, the overcrowded lineups feel more like a chaotic free-for-all than a serene surf session. Hotels and restaurants here cater heavily to tourists, leaving little of the original charm behind. And while the nightlife is bustling, it overshadows the relaxed pura vida vibe that makes Costa Rica’s surf culture so special.
Alternative Recommendation
Playa Avellanas – Just 30 minutes south, you’ll find a slice of authentic Costa Rica. This spot, often referred to as “Little Hawaii,” delivers consistent breaks for surfers of all levels and boasts stunning scenery. Picture this—fewer crowds, crystal-clear water, and Lola the pig, the infamous local mascot, roaming the beach. You’ll find both peace and waves here, without the commercialized hustle of Tamarindo.
2. Jaco Beach
Why It’s Overrated
Jaco Beach’s proximity to San José makes it an easy entry point for tourists, especially first-time visitors. But convenience comes at a cost. The town is more urbanized than its surroundings, with high-rise buildings dotting the coastline and a nightlife scene that often feels excessive. The waves here? They’re generally mediocre compared to what Costa Rica has to offer, especially with its crowded, beginner-heavy breaks that lack the magic other spots deliver.
Alternative Recommendation
Playa Hermosa – A quick 10-minute drive south of Jaco, Playa Hermosa is where the real action lives. This stretch of coastline is famous for its consistent, heavy waves ideal for intermediate and advanced surfers. Bonus points for its serene vibe—Hermosa stays true to the pura vida lifestyle with uncrowded morning sessions and epic sunrises.
3. Santa Teresa
Why It’s Overrated
Dreamy at a glance, Santa Teresa has become a victim of its own glowing reputation. Its dusty roads are now overrun with ATVs, its prices are higher than the waves, and its once-spacious lineup is now a global hotspot for everyone and their GoPros. While the beach remains stunning, the overdevelopment has replaced rustic, laid-back charm with inflated eco-trendy tourism.
Alternative Recommendation
Mal País – Just a stone’s throw away, Mal País offers everything you love about Santa Teresa—wide-open beaches, solid surf breaks, and a bohemian vibe—minus the overwhelming crowds and traffic jams. Perfect for intermediate surfers seeking variety, the mix of beach and reef breaks here ensures there’s always something to ride. Plus, it’s still the kind of place where you’ll run into locals happy to share a lineup and a story.
4. Playa Grande
Why It’s Overrated
Playa Grande, with its long, powerful waves, gets hyped as an alternative to Tamarindo, but it often ends up overcrowded for that very reason. During peak times, surfers spill over from nearby beaches, leading to packed lineups that rival Tamarindo’s busiest days. And while Grande does offer solid waves, its lack of vibrant nightlife and local culture can leave something to be desired for those seeking a well-rounded experience.
Alternative Recommendation
Playa Negra – Head further down the coast to Playa Negra for a right-hand reef break that’s famous for its clean, consistent waves. Not only will you score great surf, but you’ll also enjoy the chill, small-town vibes that feel like the Costa Rica of old. This spot’s authenticity, paired with a stellar surf scene, makes it a must for those wanting to get off the beaten path.
5. Dominical
Why It’s Overrated
Dominical markets itself as quaint and untamed, but the surf here is notoriously fickle. On the wrong day, the waves are either flat or dangerously heavy, which can be a dealbreaker for most surfers outside the expert crowd. The beach itself has a wild, rugged edge, but it doesn’t exude the postcard-perfect charm that many travelers expect. Combine this with crowds and rising prices, and you’ve got a tough sell.
Alternative Recommendation
Uvita – Just 15 minutes south, Uvita is a breath of fresh air. With uncrowded beaches, lush headlands, and pristine surf conditions, it’s an ideal haven for beginners and intermediates. Advanced surfers can also find nearby point breaks that are as rewarding as they are isolated. Add in the stunning natural beauty, complete with jungle views and cascading waterfalls, and Uvita offers the kind of authentic experience that Dominical lacks.
Insider Tips for Avoiding Crowds and Finding Authentic Waves
Travel During Shoulder Seasons
Costa Rica’s two surf seasons—dry (December to April) and wet (May to November)—bring different crowds. To experience consistent swells minus the crowds, aim for the shoulder months like November or May. You’ll find fewer surfers, better deals, and pristine conditions.
Hire a Local Guide
Some of the best surf spots in Costa Rica are tucked away beyond tourist maps and GPS directions. Locals know where the magic happens and can lead you to spots where nature, not crowds, reigns supreme.
Explore the Caribbean Coast
While Costa Rica’s Pacific coast gets all the glory, the Caribbean coast has its moments of brilliance too. During peak swell months (November to March), spots like Puerto Viejo’s Salsa Brava offer epic sessions for those willing to explore beyond the usual.
Stay Mobile
Rent a 4x4 vehicle and hit the road. Costa Rica’s hidden surf gems—like Marbella’s remote beaches or Punta Uva’s reef breaks—are worth a little extra effort to uncover.
“Waves of Wisdom”
Costa Rica is every surfer’s dream, but not all surf spots are created equal. Skipping the overrated for the underrated not only ensures better waves but also deeper connections to the pura vida lifestyle that makes this country so special. Adventuring just a little further off the beaten path? That’s where you’ll discover the magic, the stoke, and the experience you’ll treasure forever.
Be sure to check out our Costa Rica Travel page for more Costa Rica surf and travel info. And grab some local style at our Surf Shop before your trip. For sure! A simple “pura vida” goes a long way here, so does repping the local team to start a conversation, make some friends, and let everyone know you want to be here and you’re here to surf. Because you’re one of the good ones. “Let’s Look Good Out There”.
Plus, we have tons more blogs to help you get your bearings, find your right spot, and get it wired. Join us and tag us on social and subscribe to our twice-monthly newsletter for rad event invites, news, real good discounts, and all things Costa Rica surf. We’re not trying to crowd the lineup in your email or drop in on your inbox, just trying to let you know what’s out the back and help you time it up for your set wave. Pura Vida!
Pack your board, keep your spirit of adventure alive, and paddle out. The real Costa Rica is waiting for you. Pura vida y buenas olas!
